Wednesday, November 11, 2009

The Right P/E For The S&P 500

As the market has continued to soar while corporate profits have continued to plummet, many market observers have noted that the P/E level of the S&P 500 has risen to such an extent that an overvalued market is now upon us. Indeed, Standard and Poor's reports a P/E for the S&P 500 of 122, which is clearly above the index's historical range. Does this constitute a clear signal to value investors to stay away? Not on its own.

The problem with this measure of the market's valuation is that, at times, earnings may be temporarily depressed. During recessions, unanticipated drops in revenue occur which catch companies off-guard. Companies cut their costs in reaction to these revenue shocks, but there is a lag. To demonstrate this, consider the following chart depicting the profit margin level of the S&P 500 in the aggregate:

In every recession, profit margins temporarily shrink. Therefore, to justify what appears to be a ridiculously high P/E, we do not presume incredible growth in sales or returns on capital as was the norm in the late 90s. Instead, we consider what the earnings would look like when the write-downs and impairments are complete, and companies have returned to a more normal operating environment.

(As an aside, notice how strong profit margins were in particular during the expansion that preceeded this recession. This could be due to the growth that occurred in the financial industry, where margins tend to be higher as we saw here.)

Based on the above chart, the average margin for the S&P 500 appears to be around 5-6%. Using this number to determine the normalized earnings level of the index gives the S&P 500 a P/E of around 20.

Though this is a more useful calculation of the market's P/E from the perspective of a long-term investor, this still does not suggest the market is cheap. Earnings are determined by multiplying profit margins with sales; with high unemployment and tighter lending standards, the sales level of the index may shrink further from this level, reducing earnings further.

Furthermore, within the index itself, some companies will fare better than others. Many companies will be unable to handle the depressed earnings environment (due to debt or other fixed obligations) and will therefore fail. But companies with flexible cost structures will be able to return to profit margin levels commensurate with their histories, and investors who identify such companies could find themselves with returns that outperform the index.
* Source: Thanks to William Hester of Hussman Funds for the profit margin chart.

This article was written by Saj Karsan of Barel Karsan. If you enjoyed this article, please vote for it by clicking the Buzz Up! button below.

Recent Posts From DIV-Net Members